12 Valentine’s Day Food Gifts That Look Good and Taste Even Better

Everything is under $75.
Samantha Weiss-Hills Avatar
Domino-Valentines-Day-Food-Gifts-2025-FEATURE

Share

We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs.

Highlights

Many people will tell you not to gift a heart-shaped box of chocolate or really anything sweet on Valentine’s Day—that it’s basic, expected. But we’re here to say that dessert is quite welcome, and can even be exciting if you’re looking in the right places. Better yet: why not go a little spicy? Whether it’s a tingling cocktail addition, movie theater-inspired candy bars, or a fancy box of fruit, these are 12 Valentine’s Day food gifts that won’t disappoint.

Branche No. 3 Olive Oil

Branch

No. 3 Olive Oil

$44
Shop Now

Gift this bottle with a cruet or a serving dish and you’ll be in business. And Branche isn’t just a pretty face—the brand makes delicious olive oil with distinct profiles. No. 3 is crafted with two different presses of Spanish Arbequina olives, one that’s more mellow and the other that’s a little spicy. “Bold yet harmonious,” just like your love.

Disco Inferno Liquid Heat

Big Night

Disco Inferno Liquid Heat

$24
Shop Now

Spice up their cocktail hour with this chili- and botanical-infused brandy. Bird’s Eye, Scotch Bonnet, Aji Panca, and Chiltepin chilis are balanced with cinnamon and mint to give margaritas and negronis a kick. Our tip: gift with their favorite spirit or a set of glasses that go with their favorite drink.

Bon Bon Valentine’s Day Rouge Gift Box

Bon Bon

Valentine’s Day Rouge Gift Box

$30
Shop Now

Somehow, Bon Bon’s Swedish candies just never get stale. This limited-edition gift box is filled with a pound of the brand’s best-selling sour and sweet bites. 

Yun Hai Taiwanese Fruit Jams

Yun Hai

Taiwanese Fruit Jams, 4-Pack

$60
Shop Now

If fruit is their love language, gift them this quartet of small batch Taiwanese jams, including Irwin mango, mulberry, passionfruit pumpkin, and red guava. These flavorful, natural spreads are ideal on biscuits and yogurt, swirled into cakes, and mixed into cocktails. 

Knipschildt Valentine’s Day Chocolate Truffles Box

Anthropologie

Knipschildt Valentine’s Day Chocolate Truffles Box

$78
Shop Now

Tell us this isn’t the most beautiful box of chocolates you’ve ever seen, from the floral-flecked box to the splatterware-esque truffles. Made with unique flavors like blue agave, tangerine, hibiscus, and more, these sweets will delight anyone who receives them.

Ghia x Alice Mushrooms Happy Ending Ghianduja

Ghia x Alice Mushrooms

Happy Ending Ghianduja

$32
Shop Now

Ghia is our go-to for cans of N/A concoctions, but did you know they also make an alluring hazelnut spread? Mix that with crushed almonds, puffed quinoa, and Alice mushrooms (complete with nootropics, adaptogens, and other compounds that enhance desire) and the mood is set for sharing. An extra gift that comes with this gift: 100% of profits will be donated to families impacted by the Los Angeles wildfires.

Olivieri 1882 Valentine’s Cake

Olivieri 1882

Valentine's Cake

$65
Shop Now

From the brand we trust to do panettone right comes a Valentine’s cake worth giving. Made by hand with the same dough as their flagship product, this version incorporates candied strawberries and dark chocolate. Maybe it’s the shareable snack you bring to Galentine’s or you reserve it all for you and your honey. That’s up to you.

Flamingo Estate Mini Rose Honey

Flamingo Estate

Mini Rose Honey

$20
Shop Now

Flamingo Estate immediately reminds us that rose and honey are indeed both aphrodisiacs, and their Damask rose-infused honey brings both together. Make a theme: bring a bouquet, this mini jar, and something lovely to drizzle it on.

Levain Bakery

Valentine’s Day Cookie Bundle

$64
Shop Now

A limited-edition tin of over-the-top, six-ounce cookies means you don’t even have to wrap this one. Choose their favorite Levain assortment, whether that’s Signature, Decadent, Chocolate Lovers, or Dark Days of Winter. Gift them stationary or a set of water color pencils and a sketchbook to store inside once the treats are all gone.

A24 Triple Feature Movie Chocolate Set

A24

Triple Feature Movie Chocolate Set

$33
Shop Now

If heading to the movies is your regular date night, let us recommend A24’s film-inspired, six-bar chocolate set for a night in. The three flavors included are Fizzy Fountain Soda, Popcorn & Candy, Salty Peanut Crunch—one for both of you in each style.

Frog Hollow Moro Blood Oranges

Frog Hollow Farm

Organic Moro Blood Oranges

$42
Shop Now

If strawberries feel too on the nose, why not send midwinter pick-me-up citrus? Frog Hollow Farm packs up the best boxes of mail-order fruit, including these Moro blood oranges. They’re delicious just peeled and eaten, but you could also pair them with a bottle of prosecco or tonic to share with your loved one.

Flowerhead Tea

Big Night

Double Mint Rose Flowerhead Tea

$22
Shop Now

For the person you know that prefers anything over flowers. This drinkable version of roses combines with spearmint, peppermint, and gunpowder pearls to make a full-bodied green tea that ends with a floral-minty flourish. Make it a gift box with tea cups or a teapot, if you want to go the extra mile. It comes in a 50-pack on the brand’s site, too.

Samantha Weiss-Hills Avatar

Samantha Weiss-Hills

Managing Editor, Home & Shopping

Samantha Weiss-Hills is the managing editor of home and shopping for Domino. She edits and writes home tours, shopping guides, and features, and she’s the friend who everyone texts for glassware, sofa, and sheet recommendations. She lives in Brooklyn with her husband, Alex, and their beagle-corgi, Elsa.