How Maggie Gyllenhaal Prepared to Play a 1970s Porn Star

The actress shares the rich inspirations behind her fearless new role in HBO’s The Deuce.

Maggie Gyllenhaal Portrait

photography by VICTORIA WILL


Styling by Adam Ballheim | Hair by Anthony Campbell at The Wall Group | Makeup by Deanna Melluso for Kevyn Aucoin

Creative chameleon Maggie Gyllenhaal takes on a game-changing role in HBO’s The Deuce, premiering Sunday, September 10, that’s equal parts grit and grace. At one of the actress’s favorite haunts, the Neue Galerie New York, she shares a rich arsenal of inspirations as far-reaching as her talent.

It was opening night at the prestigious Berlin International Film Festival earlier this year, and Maggie Gyllenhaal was running late. “I put on this hot pink Gucci dress with a huge purple flower at the neck,” she says. “I remember looking in the mirror and the 14-year-old part of me was like, ‘You can’t wear this, it’s insane!’ I had to take a breath and say, ‘No, actually, you’re 39. You like this dress. Keep it on.’ It’s one of my favorite things that I’ve ever worn.” 

The actress knows all about risk and reward. She brings this same take-no-prisoners attitude to her richly varied career, which includes an Oscar nomination for the countrified musical Crazy Heart opposite Jeff Bridges and a Golden Globe win for the BBC miniseries The Honourable Woman.

But she’s at her fearless best this fall in The Deuce, an HBO series (from The Wire team) about the burgeoning porn scene in 1970s New York. Starring opposite James Franco as twin brothers, Gyllenhaal pulls off an even more impressive double act as Eileen “Candy” Merrell, a mother who turns tricks by night.

She fully embodies the role in wild blonde curls and a rabbit fur coat. “I want everyone I play  to have a personal style. But they all look totally different,” explains Gyllenhaal. “I wanted Candy to be like cotton candy. I wanted to be yummy. I wanted to be soft. That coat felt like her.”  

[On Gyllenhaal: Purple Printed Dress by Miu Miu; Olive Chunky Platform Sandals by Paul Andrew; Egg Dangle Oxidized Bronze Drop Earrings and Oval Bangle Bracelets by Ted Muehling.]

Maggie Gyllenhaal Portrait the deuce

photography by VICTORIA WILL


Preparation for the part began two years ago in earnest and hit fever pitch last summer. Gyllenhaal and her husband, actor Peter Sarsgaard, live in a brownstone in Park Slope, Brooklyn, but he took their two daughters to the couple’s country house so she could focus.

Gyllenhaal sought out art and films that captured the up-all-night Manhattan of the era: Nan Goldin’s The Ballad of Sexual DependencyMean Streets (“The wildness of De Niro’s work—it’s like you can’t even understand how he does it”); and The Panic in Needle Park. She read Porno Star and met with Annie Sprinkle, a performance artist who was a prostitute in the ’70s.

The payoff is visible behind Candy’s defiant eyes; this woman refuses to be defined by her circumstances. “When she’s making a porn, she’s interested in the lighting,” Gyllenhaal explains. “What’s the bounce, what does the frame of the lens do? She has no moral judgment. She is an artist.” 

In fact, Gyllenhaal wouldn’t sign on to the project unless she could also be a producer. “I’d read the first three scripts,” she recalls. “I really liked them. I was compelled by Candy. But I can’t play a prostitute without a guarantee that what we’re going to say is something I can get behind. I knew my body would be required for this part. I also wanted my mind to be used. My agents, my managers, my friends—they said, ‘You’re never going to get a producing credit. That’s really ballsy that you asked.’ But HBO came back and they gave it to me.”

The story The Deuce tells is ultimately a thrilling, dark exploration of female empowerment. And those themes, says Gyllenhaal, who uses social media as a megaphone for her support of women’s rights, have only taken on a deeper significance: “We’re talking about sexual politics in 1971. But we’re going to use that as a way of considering ourselves today. It’s easier to look at it with a little distance.” She adds, "It’s the perfect time to have a piece about women and sex and power and money.”

[On Gyllenhaal: Velvet Floral-Print Suit by Alberta Ferretti; Metallic Peep-Toe Pumps by Christian Louboutin; Egg Dangle Oxidized Bronze Drop Earrings by Ted Muehling. Throughout: Black Diamond/Gold Band Stacking Rings by Wwake; Gold Stacking Ring by Ted Muehling; Gyllenhaal’s own diamond engagement ring and gold wedding band.]

Black Graphic Maggie Gyllenhaal the deuce

photography by VICTORIA WILL


Here, Gyllenhaal talks us through her many inspirations for The Deuce. Clockwise from top left:

My Brilliant Friend: Neapolitan Novels, Barnes and Noble, Book One from $10.45
“I read the news obsessively. And I read tons of fiction. I’m really into Elena Ferrante. Her Neapolitan novels are so starkly honest in their search for truth about human experiences. Even though the characters’ circumstances are very different from mine, I relate to the darkness and the light in what she says.”

Dancer1923, by Atelier d’Ora
“My girlfriend and I gave each other this poster as a gift from the Neue bookshop. It’s an incredible image of a woman [dancer and actress Anita Berber] with this lion’s mane of hair who is just clearly worth paying attention to.”

Self-Portrait With Arm Twisted Above Head, 1910, by Egon Schiele
“The Neue has this huge collection of Gustav Klimt and Egon Schiele, who used to draw portraits in white, orange, and black on this beautiful brown paper. I wallpapered my living room with craft paper to make it feel like one of his drawings.”
Private Collection, courtesy of Neue Galerie (Photo courtesy of Hulya Kolabas for Neue Galerie)

Chandelier Earrings, Sophia Buhai
“Sophie Buhai is a friend and makes silver jewelry that looks like Georgia O’Keeffe would have worn it.” 

Porno Star by Tina Russell 

[On Gyllenhaal: Navy Embroidered Jacket and Velvet Floral Print Trousers by Alberta Ferretti, Olive Branch Necklace and Petal Necklace by Ted Muehling.]

Black Graphic the deuce

photography by VICTORIA WILL


De Maria restaurant in Nolita
“I love the way it feels at De Maria. The restaurant’s walls are like pink plaster. It’s as if you’re in a church in Santa Fe, New Mexico. There’s a high window that the sun shines through…”
(Photo courtesy of Nicole Franzen)

The Ballad of Sexual Dependency by Nan Goldin
“I went to Nan Goldin’s The Ballad of Sexual Dependency at the Museum of Modern Art earlier this year. It was a slideshow where you sat in the dark for 45 minutes with a mixtape playing. I just looked at these people in New York who reminded me of Candy. They live in a somewhat separate world. They have different touchstones, they have different style. I was really inspired by that.”
(Photo courtesy of Aperture)

Look 7, Gucci, Pre-Fall 2017
“All the wild, beautiful Gucci dresses I’m seeing around are so incredible.” 

Persona Poster by Midnight Marauder
This fall, Gyllenhaal is preparing to shoot The Kindergarten Teacher. “It’s a thriller about a woman who is a teacher and a poet. She gets obsessed with this child in her class and starts to think he’s a poetic genius.” The moody black-and-white films of Swedish director Ingmar Bergman were an influence, Gyllenhaal says, adding: “If we’re lucky, I hope it feels like we’ve been influenced by him.” 

Josef Hoffmann Pendant Lamp (1903), Neue Galerie, $795 

Published on September 06, 2017 - 6:00am EDT

Next Story

Why We’re Falling Hard for This New Pop-Up

Jayson Home’s NYC brick-and-mortar personifies cozy chic.

Read Next Story
from around the web