Everyone Told This Designer to Open Up Her Prewar Apartment’s Layout—Here’s Why She Didn’t

Share

We may earn revenue from the products available on this page and participate in affiliate programs.

large hallway

How excited can you get over a hallway? For interior decorator Sarah Lederman, whose entryway is a huge part (both literally and practically) of her Manhattan apartment, the answer is a lot. “It’s where my kids scoot up and down, have relay races…it’s where I can host a large dinner party and store the stroller and the dog’s leashes,” she says of the Upper West Side space she shares with her husband, Evan, their two kids, and goldendoodle, Ziggy. 

dog sitting in hallway
Custom Rug and Braided Rug, Temple Studio; Vintage Sofa, Ruby Beets; Throw Pillow, KRB.
woman sitting in chair
Freddie Two-Tier Table by Lacquer Company, KRB; Rug, ABC Carpet & Home; Hamble Fabric, Fermoie; Bali Jute Tassel Fringe, Samuel and Sons; Vase, Fielding Clayworks.

The area commands so much precious real estate that everyone from Lederman’s mom to her architect suggested reconfiguring it to open out the apartment’s footprint, but the segregation of the dining room, sitting room, and three bedrooms is exactly what appealed to the designer about the Emery Roth–designed prewar building. “I like to live in rooms, not one big, lofty space,” she shares. So she accessorized the area with a petite vintage slipcovered sofa that is perfect for her daughters, Gemma (5) and Isabel (2), to sit on while they put on their shoes (which are cleverly stored on a slide-out tray underneath) and a shallow console table. 

traditional living room
Pointing Paint, Farrow & Ball; Belgian Classic Roll Arm Three-Seat-Cushion Sofa, RH; Swivel Chair, Lee Industries; Farrah Fabric, Tulu Textiles; Vintage Coffee Table; Minna and Amboseli Throw Pillows, Nzuri Textiles; Samode Saffron Linen Cushion, Water G; Lamps, Ruby Beets; Art by RF Alvarez, Dan Lederman, Stephen Lavis, and Andrew Zimmerman
TV cabinet
bookshelf
Clunch Paint, Farrow & Ball; Roosevelt Sconce Metal Shade, Ann Morris Lighting; Vintage Danish Armchair; Throw Pillow, SL & Co.; Green Squiggle Vase, Morgan Peck

Lederman, who had previously rented across the city, squashed expectations further by leaning into the bones of the apartment and adding her own flair to it, rather than embarking on a textbook modernization. This meant embracing the property’s characterful paneling in the sitting room, which she covered in distinctive chalky paint (she lucked out with the existing built-ins, which feature bifold doors to hide the TV). A traditional roll-arm sofa mingles with mid-century pieces she’s owned for years, including a travertine coffee table and Danish accent chairs, and newly acquired contemporary art from Sears-Peyton Gallery. “If you have a classic base, then I feel like you can layer anything in,” she says of her approach to decorating. 

blue floral dining room
Garrison Hang Light, The Urban Electric Co.; Tablecloth and Handmade Copper Flowers, SL & Co.; Hoffman Side Chair, DWR; Vase by Jun Tsunoda, RW Guild; Rattan Round Placemats, Cutter Brooks; Art by Agnes Barley, Sears Peyton Gallery.
kitchen with blue cabinets
Light Blue Paint, Farrow & Ball; Cafe Latte Crackle Tile, Walker Zanger; Marble Utility Canister, Hawkins New York; Marble Mortar and Pestle and Hand-Hammered Copper Couscoussier, Williams Sonoma; Oval Lacquered Frame, Matilda Goad & Co.
jungle inspired nursery
Bellewood Wallpaper, Rebel Walls; Caravan Crib, Kalon Studios; Monte Pom-Pom Cushion, Pampa; Sheepskin, Jenni Kayne.

Excited to have a dining room for the first time, Lederman’s exposure to countless wall coverings and fabrics for her day job meant that “off the bat, I knew this was going to be my moment to do something bold” she says. Cue a busy, English garden–style wallpaper, juxtaposed with colorful modern artworks. “That balance of the traditional with a surprising twist is just very me,” she says. 

blue shower curtain
Custom Mediterranean Tile, Tabarka Studio; Shower Curtain, Anthropologie; Showerhead and Faucet, Waterworks; Custom Fabricated Travertine Tile, ABC Stone.

The spots requiring more than a considered paint and paper job were the bathrooms, which were original to the almost century-old apartment. The girls’ space also had to multitask as a guest powder room, “so I had to figure out how to create a jewel-box moment while meeting the needs of my kids,” explains Lederman. Her solution? Dimmable wall sconces for ambient lighting when friends come over and, ingeniously, a textured shower curtain to hide their multitude of plastic bath toys. Custom tabarka tile, unlacquered brass fixtures, and travertine stone make the space feel suitably luxe while appealing to a child’s sensibility. “My daughters love that they have this flowery bathroom of their own,” says Lederman.

beige fish scale tile
Ogee Drop Tile, Fireclay Tile; Henry Ceiling Shower Rose, Waterworks.

In the primary suite, it was out with the tub (the couple almost never take baths) and in with a double shower, complete with a wide bench. Lederman continued the use of warmer travertine over marble to create a zen, hammam-like look. Drawn to Fireclay’s fish-scale tile, she settled on three neutral tones and used a computer program to select the colors so that there are no repetitive clusters. “I suppose you could say it is perfectly randomized,” she says, laughing. 

wood bed frame
New White Paint, Farrow & Ball; Chiselhurst Bed, Lawson-Fenning; Conrad Nightstands, Made Goods; Cane Drum Stool, Jayson Home; Bedding, Jeanette Farrier; Armchair, Anthropologie; Custom Lamps, Humble Matter; Linen Box Quilt, Parachute; Accent Pillow, Pat McGann; Custom Rug, Temple Studio; Beatrice Bouquet Fabric, Schumacher.
wood dowel bed freame
wavy wood dresser
Vintage Edmond J. Spence Dresser, Chairish; Mirror, CB2; Brass Ball Zebra Boudoir Table Lamp, Blackman Cruz; Single Stem Vase, Simone Bodmer Turner.

Lederman’s breezy bedroom continues the serene vibe and features her favorite piece of furniture: a wavy-edged dresser. A trophy piece she’d lusted after for years (and acquired previously for clients to the tune of thousands of dollars on 1stDibs), it finally landed in her lap thanks to an eBay alert. Although it was in poor condition when it shipped from the Midwest, it was nothing her restorer couldn’t fix. “I look everywhere—Chairish, secondhand stores, I’ve even found things on the Dixie Highway. Everything eventually comes up,” says Lederman. Her bedside lamps are further evidence of her collaborative spirit: Months of admiring Brooklyn-based John Born’s ceramics (aka @humblematter) on Instagram inspired her to reach out to see if he could make a pair of bases in his signature plastery, sculptural style. “He’d never made lamps before, but he ran with it,” says Lederman, who sent him references by Alberto Giacometti and had the pieces wired by a specialist in the city.

gingham wallpaper playroom
Nelson Ball Wall Sconces, Herman Miller; Broderick Daybed, Serena & Lily; Finley Play Table, Pottery Barn Kids; Bow Chairs, Poppie Toys; Roll-Down Curtains, The Shade Store.
blue gingham wallpaper
Custom Lauren Check Wallpaper, Peter Fasano; Infinity Round Wall Mirror, CB2; Dresser, West Elm; Floral Table Lamp by Rebekah Miles for Nickey Kehoe; Custom Lampshade, Sarah Blomfield.

The pattern-heavy girls’ bedrooms are Lederman’s “wheelhouse.” The picture moldings in Gemma’s room (used as a playroom by her little sister) act as playful frames for a gingham wallpaper. Isabel’s space is much smaller but scores just as highly on the design front: The room was blighted with steam pipes, niches, and air vents, so Lederman covered every surface in a scenic wallpaper to create a Where the Wild Things Are setting that even Gemma, despite her larger spot, is envious of. Both children have toys and books curated onto plexiglass ledges and cubbyholes, so as not to break up the beautiful wall coverings their mom painstakingly sourced. It all seems quite grown-up, but playtime spills out everywhere, including the gem of a hallway. “Nothing is off-limits,” says Lederman. “We’re not afraid to let our kids romp throughout the apartment.” 

The Goods

Ogee Drop Tile, Fireclay

Shop Now

White Round Wall Mirror, CB2

$250
Shop Now

Flowerberry Blue Wallpaper, Penny Morrison

Shop Now

Roosevelt Sconce, Ann Morris

Shop Now

Go-to local vintage shops: Gerald Bland and Housing Works.

Favorite local home store: Côte à Coast (for baskets), Il Buco Vita (for kitchenware), KRB (for decor).

Where I buy plants: Foliage Garden.

Decor site I’ve bookmarked: My own home decor site, launching soon!

Biggest splurge: The pleated silk Sari lampshades.

Biggest save: The vintage Edmond Spence dresser I sourced on eBay.

Who to Know

I loved working with: My upholsterer, Luther Quintana.

Nicest contractor I’ve ever met: All Dimension Construction.

Pristine painter: Robert Star.

Genius landscaper: Sawyer Berson.

Meticulous wallpaper installer: Amir Hasan.

Other highly recommended craftspeople: Temple Studio (for custom rugs), decorative painter Frank Reijnen, and architect Studio Lyon Szot.

One thing I wish I knew before renovating: Be skeptical of the lowest bid. A quality contractor will be realistic about the budget it will truly take to complete the job, rather than submitting a more appealing number.

Olivia Lidbury is a freelance writer based in the U.K. She has been regularly contributing to Domino since 2021, pitching charming British houses, whimsical apartments and must-see vacation stays. Olivia also regularly writes for a number of national U.K. titles such as The Times and The Sunday Times Style magazine. She lives just outside of London in Kent.