The Cool Girl’s Guide to a City Hall Wedding

This Brooklyn couple barely had to leave their own backyard to say “I do.”

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

On writer Molly Young’s first date with graphic designer and director Teddy Blanks, they hung out on her rooftop in Chinatown. “We went to my apartment and I forced him to play the piano while I lay on the floor and listened. I remember that I really liked the way he smelled,” says the New York Times Magazine contributor, who also creates crossword puzzles for the paper.

A little over a year later, on New Year’s Eve, while standing by the counter drinking tequila in their Williamsburg loft, Blanks popped the question with an antique diamond infinity band—then presented her with a custom crossword puzzle that contained WILL YOU MARRY ME? “I started laughing!” says Young. “I couldn’t help it.”

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

Afterward, they ate a picnic of caviar and fancy cheese and watched TV. Young approached the whole wedding-planning process with the same cool, creative attitude she brings to her work and life: “Basically, we winged the whole thing!”

Here, she shares her DIY guide to a fun, laid-back wedding for the cool girl who doesn’t give a damn about fluffy dresses, flowers, or fancy food. (Warning: Uptight bridezillas need not apply.)

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

Going to the Chapel, er, City Hall 

“That morning,” says Young, “I washed my hair and hoped for the best.” A makeup artist she found on Instagram gave her a coppery smoky eye. (“I wanted to do insane raccoon glitter, but she said no.”) Young paired pink pom-pom kitten heels with a custom white pantsuit inspired by Bianca Jagger; Blanks wore a Perry Ellis crossword puzzle tie scored on eBay.

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

While exploring the City Hall neighborhood, Blanks and Young made kitschy-cool party stores the ultimate wedding photo-op spots. The bride forgot about a bouquet, but a friend picked up “weird orange flowers that look like brains.”

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

After taking a number and waiting in line, the couple was eventually ushered—along with their parents and childhood friends—into a room. “The whole thing took 80 seconds,” says Young. 

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

Her leopard-print enamel wedding ring was equally easy: “I got it from the Real Real for $100.” After pics were snapped on the stairs outside the Marriage Bureau, which were “covered in confetti from previous weddings,” the newlyweds strolled to the Odeon Restaurant. 

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER
Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER
Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

Eat, Drink, AND Be Married

At the Odeon—a 10-minute walk from City Hall and a Manhattan institution—everyone feasted on hamburgers, french fries, doughnuts, and “lots of champagne!” says Young, who loves the restaurant’s “old-school New York, 1980s vibe.”

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

Skipping catering and venue renting allowed the couple to focus on having a good time with way less stress. That night, Blanks and Young stayed at the Greenwich Hotel in Tribeca (a present from her brother), where they “jumped on the bed, ordered tons of room service, used all the toiletries, and fell asleep by 9.”

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER
Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

There’s No Place Like Home

The next day, Young prepped for the post-wedding celebration, hosted in their apartment. “My brother brought over 30 cases of fancy beer that we put on ice,” she says. A bartender, whom they found on Yelp, made signature drinks like bourbon mint juleps (a nod to Blanks’s Southern roots).

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

Pies ’n’ Thighs, a nearby fried chicken joint, delivered banana cream pies and bite-size chicken biscuits. Young placed brightly colored bowls of jelly beans and Pop Rocks around the apartment, as well as custom-printed napkins featuring “lyrics from the classic Kool & the Gang wedding jam.”

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

Blanks put together a playlist, with Prince, Otis Redding, and Zapp & Roger in heavy rotation. 

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

When it comes to a big party, a self-serve bar is the way to go once the bartender packs up.

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

Picking up on a canary-hued side table, the bright yellow paper plates and vintage bowls create a strong color theme.

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER
Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

Young concealed unsightly extension cords with plastic ivy.

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

At 2 a.m., when the last of the 140 guests had left, Young ate a whole banana cream pie in her pajamas: “The next morning, I treated myself to a cleaning service so I could just sit around and relax and recap the whole night. That’s the best part of any party.” 

Photography by MEGHAN MCNEER

This story originally appeared in the Winter 2017 issue with the headline The Cool Girl’s Guide to a City Hall Wedding (in 3 Easy Parts).

See more wedding ideas:
The Emerald Engagement Rings Non-Traditional Brides Will Love
Non-Traditional Wedding Guest Book Ideas That Wow
These Are the Biggest Wedding Trends for 2018

Published on January 10, 2018 - 7:30am EST

Next Story

8 Mid-Range Furniture Brands That Aren’t Ikea

It may be time to retire the flatpack approach.

Read Next Story
from around the web